Skip to content

Redefining your marketing strategy by leveraging Pinterest with Sarah Erickson

If you’re feeling burnt out on Instagram and want to find a new way to market your business that offers longevity and sustainability, this episode is for you. Sarah Erickson of Sarah Ann Design took her time back and created sustainable business growth when she went all in with Pinterest. 

She joins us on today’s episode to share why she believes Pinterest is ideal for list-building and why she’s happy she stopped using Instagram in her business. Listen in as she shares how to create high-quality content for Pinterest, repurpose it, and reap the benefits for years to come. 

The Independent Business podcast is powered by HoneyBook, the all-in-one platform for anyone with clients. Book clients, manage projects, get paid faster, and have business flow your way with HoneyBook. Use the code PODCAST to get 20% off your first year as a new member.

Follow the Independent Business podcast

Growing a business on Pinterest instead of Instagram

Seventy-one percent of U.S. businesses use Instagram to market themselves, but Sarah only posts on Instagram once a year. She felt that the time investment required to maintain an active social media platform wasn’t worth it for the return she was seeing. Sarah is an avid birdwatcher, and she’d much rather spend her time outdoors doing what she loves than on Instagram.

Most people don’t realize that there are still tons of ways to market your business outside of platforms like Instagram. Sarah used Pinterest to drive traffic to her website, grow her email list, and generate leads. At its peak, her business has reached nine million monthly impressions on Pinterest, much better than what she saw on Instagram.

The great thing about the Pinterest algorithm is that you don’t need to have a ton of followers to succeed. Sarah has 14,000 followers but consistently gets over six million impressions on her pins each month. It’s easier to get your work in front of new people on Pinterest than it is on Instagram.

Pinterest is a long game

On Instagram, posts lose their impact quickly after they’re published, and viral moments are getting shorter and shorter. Pinterest is a long game, which means that pins you posted a few years ago can still generate leads for you today. You need to be patient and stay consistent to see success on Pinterest, but it will pay off. 

Sarah started using Pinterest for her business around 2018, but her growth took off when she started using it to grow her email list. Pinterest is a great tool to lead people to your email list, and email subscribers are more valuable than Instagram followers.

How to create ideal content for Pinterest

Since Pinterest is a long game, you want your pins to lead to long-term offerings. Your email list and evergreen content are ideal. Your pins need to lead people to high-quality content.

The great thing about Pinterest is you only have to create one piece of high-quality content, such as a podcast episode or a blog post. You can create pins that point to that content over and over again.

Your content should also lead people to your email list. For example, if you post a pin about your blog post, the blog should include a CTA to join your list. 

Once people join your email list, you can nurture them, market to them, and have real conversations with them. 

Most people are not creating enough pins for each piece of content. Sarah creates around 100 pins for her lead magnets, which is easier than you’d think. You can add subtle variations to your pins to help you create more quickly. For example, you can use the same pin and change the background color to create two pins.

While it’s important to focus on quality, Pinterest is a quantity game. The more pins you have pointing toward a piece of content, the better that content will perform. You will always have some pins that don’t perform well, but the more pins you create, the more you will succeed.

You can learn from the pins that succeed and notice patterns so that you can try to duplicate your success. 

Keyword research strategy for Pinterest

Pinterest is a search engine, so you can also take advantage of keywords to drive more traffic. Your keyword research strategy for Pinterest doesn’t need to be complicated. Think about your target audience, what they are searching for, and the questions you regularly get asked. Then, simply provide high-quality content that meets their needs. 

How to nurture your email list

Pinterest is a great way to catch customers at the beginning of their journey and convert them to email subscribers. From there, you must nurture them to turn them into loyal customers. 

Sarah uses a 12-month nurture sequence workflow that includes one email per month. She also recycles content from her blog for her email list, which creates less work. 

If it feels overwhelming to create a year-long email sequence, remember that it will serve you for years to come. The time investment upfront is worth it for the long-term ROI. 

Join the waitlist for Sarah’s Pinterest course

Sarah is currently working on a course that will dive deeper into using Pinterest to market your business and save you time. You can join the waitlist here

The biggest differentiator between the businesses that succeed and the ones that fail

Sarah believes that the biggest differentiator between the businesses that succeed and the ones that fail is a heart for service. Customers and clients can tell when you are authentic and intentional about your offerings. 

Important sections of the conversation

  • [2:06] Sarah’s entrepreneurial journey
  • [3:54] Growing a business on Pinterest instead of Instagram
  • [7:01] Pinterest is a long game
  • [12:07] Creating high-value content for Pinterest
  • [14:08] Leveraging Pinterest for email growth
  • [15:44] Quality vs. quantity
  • [17:17] Keyword research strategy for Pinterest
  • [18:34] Leveraging data on Pinterest
  • [20:46] How to nurture your audience
  • [25:57] Batching your content
  • [27:23] Content repurposing
  • [33:12] The biggest differentiator between the businesses that succeed and the ones that fail

Resources mentioned

Connect with the guest

Blog tags:

Share to:

Related posts