Skip to content

Your guide to converting Instagram followers into customers with Michelle Gifford

Having a social media strategy that leads to real results for your business has never been more important. In this episode, Instagram expert Michelle Gifford joins us to talk about all things social media. We process the TikTok ban and how business owners should respond to it, plus we dive into how we can use Instagram to convert followers into customers.

Listen in for Michelle’s social media strategy tips and content creation hacks. She reminds us that you can be successful on social media if you go all in, lead with intention, and take action.

The Unbreakable Business podcast is powered by HoneyBook, the all-in-one platform for anyone with clients. Book clients, manage projects, get paid faster, and have business flow your way with HoneyBook. Use the code PODCAST to get 20% off your first year as a new member.

Follow the Independent Business podcast

Addressing the TikTok ban

There has been a lot of uncertainty around TikTok in the US and whether or not we’ll see the platform stay available. Unfortunately for a lot of business owners, this uncertainty is weighing heavy on the future of their business. The whole saga serves as a reminder that social media has huge influence and global implications.

For business owners who have seen success on TikTok and now feel uncertain about its future, Michelle stresses that the skills you’ve built are transferable. It’s hard to start over on a new platform, but you can use what you’ve learned from building a following on TikTok to gain success somewhere else. 

It’s also crucial to build an audience on a place of your own that a social media company can’t take away, such as an email list or Substack is ideal.  

How to be successful on Instagram in 2025

No matter what happens with TikTok, Michelle predicts that we’ll see an influx of TikTok creators on Instagram. She expects the “TikTok-ification” of Instagram to continue in 2025, which means longer-form signature content over short-form content. Say goodbye to seven-second reels with a “read the caption” hook. It’s time to go deeper with your audience.

Carousel posts are also having a moment right now. Hooking people in with value right away is also more important than ever. 

With each upcoming trend, success will be determined by whether or not you connect with your audience. To make that happen, you need to know your audience extremely well, understand their problems, and connect with them on a personal level. 

Best practices to convert Instagram followers to customers

When it comes to Instagram strategies, a sales funnel is going to be the key to finding overall success. In order to build a strong sales funnel, you should create three types of Instagram content: 

  • Attraction content to help you grow your following
  • Nurture content to develop the relationship
  • Sales content to convert them to customers

One of the most powerful tools for converting your followers into customers is ManyChat. Whether you’re looking to direct them to a specific link, get them added to your email list, or get them in your DMs, it will help your followers feel more connected to your business.

ManyChat has a few powerful features that creators may not be utilizing. Their delayed response setting will message followers a few hours after their engagement to check-in or ask a follow up question. Additionally, there is the “forced follow” feature, where people must be following you in order to receive messages from you. Turning this feature on ensures that your messages get delivered, grows your following, and helps you attain higher-quality leads. 

How to manage multiple social media platforms without getting overwhelmed

While Michelle is active on a lot of channels, she has a team supporting her. Managing multiple platforms by yourself is tricky and leads to social media burnout. If you don’t have a team helping you with social media, Michelle advises sticking to one platform. 

If you are going to be on multiple platforms, make sure you know why you’re on each one. Is it because it’s fun? Or because it introduces you to new people? Or to push a specific product? You need to understand how each platform fits into your overall strategy. 

As you post across multiple platforms, you should track how your content performs on each one. 

An effective content plan can also minimize overwhelm. It’s helpful to have one core piece of content, such as a blog, YouTube video, or podcast episode that you can create social media posts out of. The posts should point back to the core content and ultimately lead people to your email list.  

Researching content on Instagram

A helpful way to figure out what kind of Instagram content you want to create is to research what already exists on the app. As you use Instagram, pay attention to what actually makes you stop scrolling and tune into someone else’s content. What makes you follow someone or share their content? Save the content you like so that you can go back to it when you need new ideas. 

  • Keywords Everywhere is a helpful research tool that helps you discover what people are searching for on Google.
  • Later Media is also useful to help you track your analytics and see what kind of content your audience engages with. 
  • ChatGPT allows you to submit your well-performing content and ask it to analyze it for you, giving you a list of reasons why that content is doing well and how you can implement the same strategies in the future. 

Go all in with your business

Michelle’s main piece of business advice is to go all in. She wasted too much time doubting herself and dipping her toe into the entrepreneurial world. However, she found success when she dove in headfirst. To see the kind of success you want, you have to commit and push yourself out of your comfort zone to make it happen. 

Rapid fire questions

  1. Reels or carousels? Reels
  2. Best social platform for digital product sales? Instagram
  3. Best content type for Instagram account growth? Reels
  4. Favorite type of content to create? Podcasts
  5. Yes or no to using AI for content creation? It shouldn’t create content for you, but it should be a starting place
  6. Biggest social media ick? Telling how much money you just made

What does having an unbreakable business mean to you?

Michelle believes that having an unbreakable business means you keep going, even when people judge you or you fail. You have to go all in. 

Important sections of the conversation

  • [1:29] Addressing the TikTok ban
  • [7:34] How to be successful on Instagram in 2025
  • [15:15] Best practices to convert Instagram followers to customers
  • [24:46] How to manage multiple social media platforms without getting overwhelmed
  • [30:48] Researching content on Instagram
  • [37:54] Go all in with your business
  • [41:13] Rapid fire questions
  • [45:48] What does having an unbreakable business mean to you?

Resources mentioned

Connect with the guest

Blog tags:

Share to:

Related posts